Wiki home / Underkeep Puzzle Solutions: Verified Maps, Clues & Keys
Underkeep Puzzle Solutions: Verified Maps, Clues & Keys
Find verified Underkeep puzzle solutions for Hollowgrave, The Silent Riddles, Grimfen, The Rootgrave and the Soulforge maps.
Updated 2026-11-18

Underkeep's puzzles often combine one environmental observation with one repeated interaction. The solution may be a set of items placed in alcoves, torches lit in a clock pattern, a plate pressed by a creature, or an object thrown onto a hidden plate. This guide indexes the puzzle groups that currently have traceable map notes and points to the detailed solution pages.
It is deliberately an index. A puzzle stays out of this list when only an unsupported summary says that it exists, and no exact solution is invented from a map thumbnail.
Verified Underkeep puzzle solutions
| Puzzle or area | Confirmed task | Where to continue |
|---|---|---|
| Hollowgrave pressure plate | Cross the pit obstacle by using the documented object-and-plate interaction. | Hollowgrave Tunnels |
| Orc Chieftain and Silver Key | Boss drop opens the private chest; the Silver Key from that chest opens the northwestern Hollowgrave door. | Silver Key |
| The Silent Riddles: four item alcoves | Put the Pickaxe, Rock, Apple and Shovel into their four marked alcoves to open the eastern grate. | Silent Riddles solutions |
| The Silent Riddles: torch clock | The sign reads 2:35. Light the 2 o'clock and 7 o'clock torches and leave the others out. | Silent Riddles solutions |
| The Silent Riddles: Test of Dexterity | Throw any item west so it lands on the last invisible plate; the northern grate opens. | Silent Riddles solutions |
| The Silent Riddles: creature plates | Four pit-side plates require creatures to press them; they switch pits in the west corridor. | Silent Riddles solutions |
| Grimfen fog maze | Ask Grgla the Sleazy about the maze; he gives you his fish and joins as a guide. | Grimfen map and fog maze |
| Soulforge season braziers | The Outer Halls map marks the four-season sequence and its solution. | Maps index |
| Soulforge seal braziers | The Outer Halls map separates the purple and yellow seal combinations. | Maps index |
| Depths of the Broken Seal light puzzle | The map documents a 3x3 light puzzle, secret walls and the broken northwestern obelisk. | Maps index |
| The Rootgrave skull buttons | Four skull buttons toggle different sets of grates. Closing all four opens the secret wall. | The Thing |
Solve an Underkeep puzzle without guessing
Start by reading the exact sign, inscription or item description. The Silent Riddles clock is the clearest example: the sign gives 2:35, and the verified solution treats those two numbers as clock positions rather than as a quantity of torches. Guessing from the number alone would produce a different answer.
Then inspect the objects that can change state. In the riddle room, four empty alcoves tell you how many items belong there. In the torch room, the ring of twelve torches makes the clock interpretation testable. In a plate room, the objects beside the pits tell you whether a party member, thrown item or creature can press the plate.
Keep entering and leaving the room while the state is visible. A lever can open a gate and reveal the next plate. Four skull buttons in The Rootgrave each toggle a different set of grates, so pressing every button once does not necessarily solve it. The goal is the final pattern, not the number of presses.
If solving the puzzle opens a route downward, save before the next room. Several areas contain irreversible combat or long return routes. A save at the checkpoint lets you test a mechanic without repeating the whole floor.
Puzzle clues that are not solutions
A map marker can confirm that an NPC mumbles riddles without proving what each line means. The lost dwarf in Grimfen mentions red roots, monster-like cages and guardians, and those lines do connect to hazards and choices elsewhere. Still, they are clues rather than a complete key. Do not assume “do not kill every guardian you meet” by itself changes the final area; the game's comment thread shows that players can reach different outcomes only when other puzzle steps are also complete.
Likewise, a locked door does not prove that a matching key is in the same room. Cross-floor key routes are common. The Silver Key chain and the four Tentacle Roots both require you to leave the place where the locked object or boss appears.
Which large Underkeep puzzle areas are documented?
The current map index records puzzles in these locations:
- Hollowgrave Tunnels: an early pit and pressure-plate obstacle.
- The Silent Chambers and deeper Mausoleum floors: boss encounters and a deeper route, with some puzzle notes on the map.
- Depths of the Broken Seal: a 3x3 light puzzle and secret walls.
- Caerlin Woods: altar, chalices, old well and several side-cave routes.
- Grimfen and The Mireheart: fog maze, fountain sequence and swamp boss preparation.
- The Rootgrave: skull-button grate puzzle and four Tentacle Roots.
- Soulforge: season braziers, seal braziers, gardens, The Silent Riddles and the Furnace.
- Underkeep Tower: statue and plate puzzles, hidden buttons, a painting gallery and rune buttons.
Map descriptions can identify a puzzle before a full written solution exists. Use the Underkeep map index to open the specific floor, then read every note in the room. Secondary walkthrough prose can contain transcription errors when directions are paraphrased, so cross-check door and entrance positions against the labelled interactive map.
Should you solve the optional puzzles?
The verified notes show experience rewards, keys, equipment, runic segments and access to secret alcoves behind some optional puzzle sequences. They do not establish that every one is mandatory for the main ending, so avoid treating a completion checklist as a requirement. Solve a puzzle when the route, reward or character interaction is useful to your current party, and leave a clear automap marker if you choose to return later.
Report a changed Underkeep puzzle
Patch changes can alter an item name, a plate's response or the position of a secret button. A useful correction should name the area, the room marker, the current game version if visible, what you tried and what happened. Do not send only “the solution is wrong”: the map notes and in-game state need to be compared at the same location.
Sources and verification
The puzzle index was checked on November 18, 2026 against dj's Underkeep Area Maps, the linked OldGames.sk map notes for Grimfen, The Mireheart, The Rootgrave and The Silent Riddles, developer replies on The Thing, and the existing developer-verified Silver Key guide. The Steam store page documents the game's environmental-puzzle and automap systems. Exact solutions are limited to notes that could be read and cross-checked.
Sources
- dj: Underkeep Area Maps (community map index) (checked 2026-11-18)
- OldGames.sk: Grimfen map notes (checked 2026-11-18)
- Underkeep on Steam (checked 2026-11-18)